LISTS · COVERS

Covers that outshone the original

Flops, B-sides and forgotten demos that became huge in someone else's hands.

A song can sit unnoticed for years until the right voice finds it. These covers didn't just do well: they buried the first recording so completely that most listeners have never heard it.

Infographic 1/2Infographic 2/2Story image
  1. Tainted Love

    The hitSoft Cell · 1981The originalGloria Jones · 1965

    Gloria Jones's single went nowhere in 1965. Soft Cell's remake was a UK No. 1 and spent a then-record 43 weeks on the Hot 100.

    Every version of “Tainted Love” →Source ↗
    Card image
  2. I Love Rock 'n' Roll

    The hitJoan Jett & the Blackhearts · 1981The originalThe Arrows · 1975

    The Arrows released it as a B-side. Joan Jett's version spent seven weeks at No. 1 in the US.

    Every version of “I Love Rock 'n' Roll” →Source ↗
    Card image
  3. Torn

    The hitNatalie Imbruglia · 1997The originalEdnaswap · 1995

    Ednaswap's own recording barely registered. Natalie Imbruglia's spent 11 weeks at No. 1 on US radio airplay.

    Every version of “Torn” →Source ↗
    Card image
  4. Don't Know Why

    The hitNorah Jones · 2002The originalJesse Harris · 1999

    Jesse Harris recorded it with violin and guitar and sold the album on his website. Norah Jones's piano version won Record and Song of the Year.

    Every version of “Don't Know Why” →Source ↗
    Card image
  5. Respect

    The hitAretha Franklin · 1967The originalOtis Redding · 1965

    Otis Redding's original peaked at No. 35 on the pop chart. Aretha Franklin's went to No. 1 and became an anthem.

    Every version of “Respect” →Source ↗
    Card image
  6. Red Red Wine

    The hitUB40 · 1983The originalNeil Diamond · 1967

    Neil Diamond's single stalled at No. 62. UB40's reggae version topped the UK chart and, on reissue, the US Hot 100 in 1988.

    Every version of “Red Red Wine” →Source ↗
    Card image
  7. Killing Me Softly with His Song

    The hitRoberta Flack · 1973The originalLori Lieberman · 1972

    Lori Lieberman's recording didn't chart. Roberta Flack's spent five weeks at No. 1 and won two Grammys.

    Every version of “Killing Me Softly with His Song” →Source ↗
    Card image
  8. Nothing Compares 2 U

    The hitSinéad O'Connor · 1990The originalThe Family · 1985

    The Family never released it as a single. Sinéad O'Connor's version was No. 1 in the US, the UK and much of Europe.

    Every version of “Nothing Compares 2 U” →Source ↗
    Card image
  9. Without You

    The hitHarry Nilsson · 1971The originalBadfinger · 1970

    An album track for Badfinger. A No. 1 single for Harry Nilsson in the US and the UK.

    Every version of “Without You” →Source ↗
    Card image
  10. Blinded by the Light

    The hitManfred Mann's Earth Band · 1976The originalBruce Springsteen · 1973

    Springsteen's single didn't chart. Manfred Mann's Earth Band took it to No. 1 in 1977.

    Every version of “Blinded by the Light” →Source ↗
    Card image
  11. Twist and Shout

    The hitThe Beatles · 1963The originalThe Top Notes · 1961

    The Top Notes' original flopped. The Beatles' version reached No. 2 in the US in 1964.

    Every version of “Twist and Shout” →Source ↗
    Card image
  12. Girls Just Want to Have Fun

    The hitCyndi Lauper · 1983The originalRobert Hazard · 1979

    Robert Hazard's demo wasn't released at the time. Cyndi Lauper's version reached No. 2 and defined her career.

    Every version of “Girls Just Want to Have Fun” →Source ↗
    Card image
  13. Mr. Tambourine Man

    The hitThe Byrds · 1965The originalBob Dylan · 1965

    An acoustic album track for Bob Dylan. The Byrds' electric version was No. 1 in the US and UK and helped launch folk rock.

    Every version of “Mr. Tambourine Man” →Source ↗
    Card image
  14. Hallelujah

    The hitJeff Buckley · 1994The originalLeonard Cohen · 1984

    Cohen's label initially declined to release Various Positions in the US. Buckley's version became the one covered by everyone else.

    Every version of “Hallelujah” →Source ↗
    Card image
  15. Hound Dog

    The hitElvis Presley · 1956The originalBig Mama Thornton · 1953

    Big Mama Thornton's was a big R&B hit. Elvis's spent 11 weeks at No. 1 on the pop chart as a double A-side with "Don't Be Cruel".

    Every version of “Hound Dog” →Source ↗
    Card image
  16. I Will Always Love You

    The hitWhitney Houston · 1992The originalDolly Parton · 1974

    Dolly's original was a country No. 1. Whitney's became one of the best-selling singles by a woman in history.

    Every version of “I Will Always Love You” →Source ↗
    Card image
  17. Who Let the Dogs Out

    The hitBaha Men · 2000The originalAnslem Douglas · 1998

    Anslem Douglas wrote it as "Doggie" for Trinidad's carnival. The Baha Men's cover won a Grammy and became a stadium staple.

    Every version of “Who Let the Dogs Out” →Source ↗
    Card image

Know one we missed?

Every entry here is built from Musicore connections. Add a cover, sample or songwriting credit on any song page and it joins the rabbit hole.

More lists · Most-covered songs